Rebirth's Poor Ratings

[Mercy]

Professional ratings
Allmusic 2/5 stars
Entertainment W.(D+)
The Guardian 2/5 stars
Los Angeles Times 1/4 stars
New York Times (unfavorable)
NME (4/10)
Pitchfork Media (4.5/10)
Rolling Stone 2.5/5 stars
USA Today 2/4 stars
Village Voice (mixed)

WOOOW!
VERY NEGATIVE CRITISISM.
Leah Greenblatt of Entertainment Weekly gave it a D+ rating and compared Wayne's decision to record a rock album to basketball player Michael Jordan's attempt at baseball, stating "Jordan returned to the basketball court after one ill-fated season in the farm leagues; we can only hope for the same for Wayne".

[AnDz]

Re: Rebirth's Poor Ratings

that shit sux. but im not surprised.
in Denmark:

GAFFA - 4 out off 6

soundvenue - 1 out off 6

KPN - 3 out off 6

thats aiight.

[///GRAM]

Re: Rebirth's Poor Ratings

Hate to brake it to you guys but rebirth was WHACK!! It pulled through with about 3 good tracks and thats it. Please believe, Im as big of a wayne fan as all you.. I got the rebirth leak, then when the CD dropped I went and picked up a copy just to support my man wayne but I just cant dig that shit.

[YoungMoneyEnt]

Re: Rebirth's Poor Ratings

This is upsetting because I think Rebirth is a great album.
Idk what Wayne will think about this but he knows Carter IV has to be crazy now

[Dino]

Re: Rebirth's Poor Ratings

No matter how many people like it, experimental albums always get the worst reviews. Its a shame.

[///GRAM]

Re: Rebirth's Poor Ratings

Anyone have the official first week sales ??

[fifa]

Re: Rebirth's Poor Ratings

Fuck them!!
Rebirth is a great CD

[Mr Xclusive]

Re: Rebirth's Poor Ratings

i knew it...


still a great album

[Korin]

Re: Rebirth's Poor Ratings

Lmao.

I don't listen to critics.

[tha_chronic]

Re: Rebirth's Poor Ratings

Its true Rebirth is just for die hard weezy fans but fuck it..i enjoyed it and weezy still has it in em for C4 so no stress

[NolaKid504]

Re: Rebirth's Poor Ratings

fuck the critics , and like mr exclusive said , still a great album

[iGot5onit]

Re: Rebirth's Poor Ratings

idk man.. rebirth just didnt feel right. dude needs to stick to rappin.