Was Tha Carter IV really THAT bad?

[SIGHR]

Re: Was Tha Carter IV really THAT bad?

On the whole I think it is a good record and deserves a good part of the praise it gets.
But, as a fan I was disappointed...

just listen to the delivery at 2:20-2:26 on Megaman.

After S4TW came out, my roommate said "Damn, man. Wayne's dead. I didn't want it to be true."
I disagreed since I liked 6'7' and other features and figured maybe Wayne would come back with C4. After hearing Andre3k's verse on C4, I was in shock. I didnt think I had ever heard anyone show up Wayne on his own album.
Moments like those are what made C4 feel disappointing to me.

Wayne used to be superhuman.

[Murillo]

Re: Was Tha Carter IV really THAT bad?

3,5, so i voted 3.

I Liked only 6'7, Novacane, Mirror, NOTB (live version), Megaman and Blunt Blowin.

[Guest]

Re: Was Tha Carter IV really THAT bad?

2/5. It deserves nothing higher than that.

[Eazyana?]

Re: Was Tha Carter IV really THAT bad?

2/5. It deserves nothing higher than that.

This and it really has no replay value to me.

[FNS_]

Re: Was Tha Carter IV really THAT bad?

it could've been so much better. he slacked on it just like he did on sorry 4 the wait. and where is the dedication 4?

[Cap]

Re: Was Tha Carter IV really THAT bad?

4 stars

[Guest1]

Re: Was Tha Carter IV really THAT bad?

tbh, i won't ever listen to it again prolly after this year

[Shady4Ever]

Re: Was Tha Carter IV really THAT bad?

It wasn't bad. Only some fans who overreact all the time.
It had some bad lines, but so does many other albums. It's was a good album.
But still C2>>>>>>>>

[wfb804]

Re: Was Tha Carter IV really THAT bad?

It wasn't horrible, but it didnt match the expectations evry one had for it so it was basically a dissapointment to me

2/5

[IceMan]

Re: Was Tha Carter IV really THAT bad?

It wasn't bad. Only some fans who overreact all the time.
It had some bad lines, but so does many other albums. It's was a good album.
But still C2>>>>>>>>

cheap beats, getting owned by almost all features, weak flows, gay punchlines, voice sucked sometimes (lol)


overall this is definitely a 4/5

[TyIquan]

Re: Was Tha Carter IV really THAT bad?

cheap beats, getting owned by almost all features, weak flows, gay punchlines, voice sucked sometimes (lol)


overall this is definitely a 4/5

The beats did suck, but the only features were really on the Intro, Interlude, Outro. I'm pretty sure we established he sucked on that. The shit wasn't as bad as yaw say. I listened to it today and actually enjoyed it.



Though to be perfectly honest, I started it at Novacane, added Up Up & Away after I Got Some Money On Me, and after that I added Dear Anne, Told Y'all, We Be Back Soon, and Go Getter. Then I skipped the Intro and stopped listening when How To Hate came on...