C1,C2,C3 vs SSLP,MMLP,TES

[Az_Si]

c4 is better than c1

Guess it depends on what you focus on
I think that C4 has few songs that are better then C1 and few that are worse then C1 so everybody can argue I think overall a more "solid" song choice is better even though I'd rather listen to Carter 4..

[MORO551]

I'm biased, but C1, C2, C3 of course are better

[Wisheezy]

C3 > c2 > c1 > c4 imo

[Black00]

it's a wayne site , as i always say , we can't expect eminem to win it.
but it's true that eminem's discography as someone stated at least till encore is untouchable.
for me it's something like
TES>MMLP>C2>C3>SSLP>C1

(C4 is somewhere after SSLP or near it)

[Razorxx88]

Only Carter 3 over The Eminem Show

[BrewCityYM]

Guess it depends on what you focus on
I think that C4 has few songs that are better then C1 and few that are worse then C1 so everybody can argue I think overall a more "solid" song choice is better even though I'd rather listen to Carter 4..

Not Even Close . . . . . . Nothing About Tha Carter IV Is Better Than Tha Carter . . . . . From Lyrics To Production, To Flow, To All Of That

- - - Updated - - -

you honest?

yea wtf is that . . . . and it's phrased "You Serious" lol See that's why I gotta skip what half yaw be talking bout because most of yaw are foreigners and don't really know shit

[Az_Si]

Not Even Close . . . . . . Nothing About Tha Carter IV Is Better Than Tha Carter . . . . . From Lyrics To Production, To Flow, To All Of That

- - - Updated - - -



yea wtf is that . . . . and it's phrased "You Serious" lol See that's why I gotta skip what half yaw be talking bout because most of yaw are foreigners and don't really know shit

I got a few songs I'd rather listen to on C4 then C1 (6'7"/President Carter) but everybody has his opinion...And try to write German man you know what I asked so fuck it! TES = The Eminem Show MMLP= Marshall Mathers LP SSLP= Slim Shady LP
You're welcome!

[BrewCityYM]

I got a few songs I'd rather listen to on C4 then C1 (6'7"/President Carter) but everybody has his opinion...And try to write German man you know what I asked so fuck it! TES = The Eminem Show MMLP= Marshall Mathers LP SSLP= Slim Shady LP
You're welcome!

Ok So you'd rather listen to 6 foot 7 foot over the whole Carter ? ? ? even tho he spitting real raw rap ? ? from the intro tot eh outro . . . theres not one shit verse at all on that album . . . . . not one . . . . and 6 foot 7 foot, go dj, bring it back . . that shit is all the same . . it's hella songs on tha carter better than president carter

[Az_Si]

Ok So you'd rather listen to 6 foot 7 foot over the whole Carter ? ? ? even tho he spitting real raw rap ? ? from the intro tot eh outro . . . theres not one shit verse at all on that album . . . . . not one . . . . and 6 foot 7 foot, go dj, bring it back . . that shit is all the same . . it's hella songs on tha carter better than president carter

Man it's just my opinion these song hve a nearly perfect listening vibe to me and i just got a personal connection to C4 so it's probably that i know that lyrical C1 is better and C4 flow was often kinda lazy but still that's my thoughts on this topic.

[Deleted User #3]

What is up with this fascination to compare incomparable things on this forum?! They are ao fucking different we almost might as well be comparing John Mayer's discography to Tha Carter's, and even I wouldn't vote because they are so different.