The Resistance Vs. VorthaxX..who will it be?

[-Nino-]

As you may have seen the thread about this GFX battle.
Voting Will End Sunday Afternoon
Good Luck..

A.

B.

[WeezYIsCraaazY]

Re: The Resistance Vs. VorthaxX..who will it be?

It's Pretty Obvious On Which Is Which

[blownoffkush]

Re: The Resistance Vs. VorthaxX..who will it be?

both are fucking random. both dope tho.

[ProBitaz.]

Re: The Resistance Vs. VorthaxX..who will it be?

They're both dope, hard to choose.. (but I'ma go for The Resisstance's..)

[chapweezy]

Re: The Resistance Vs. VorthaxX..who will it be?

we all know who won lol

[Artille]

Re: The Resistance Vs. VorthaxX..who will it be?

I'm going with B. To me, A looks like just a couple C4Ds on a stock photo. It was a good concept, but it just wasn't good enough. Neither signature is amazing to me to be honest, but B stand out more.

[Wisheezy]

Re: The Resistance Vs. VorthaxX..who will it be?

Right here I go...


A.

The light source is fucking sick. Nice job on that. I love the render whatever it is. The C4D's are great, I love the depth you've created with them and the effect you have around the signature/artwork. I liked everything at first, and I was about to vote for you, but then I realised I didn't like the two C4D's in the right corner, they just look, out of place? Mainly the one directly on the right next to render..it just looks wrong, and also it has a sick concept but lacked the real creativity I know you have in you Vorthaxx because you're a sick designer no doubt, but didn't expect the stock BG. But oh well, great piece it's better than anything better than I can do thats for sure lol. Keep it up


B.

Resistance. I love the concept. I've always liked good card concept signature piece. Although the edges seems a little plain I think that it's kinda nice like that because it would seem too much otherwise. I also like the effect of the flames that come of the cards, it's a good effect and really makes the piece with these effects. It also adds great depth to the signature. I think that you could've done one with some text maybe? See if that was good, either way it would've probably looked good.

So overall It just edged with B.

It was close, and hard to chose IMO. But both great designs.


KIU. No hate and yes I wrote a lot because I like to give constructive criticism and good points

[vorthaxX]

Re: The Resistance Vs. VorthaxX..who will it be?

oh noes, not again

my render: http://planetrenders.net/renders/alb...556256/653.png
my stock: http://img163.imageshack.us/img163/1...770f078160.jpg
blending wasnt too easy.. took some time =P

anyway.. tx wisheezy for the criticism
i use alot of these "random c4ds" so yea.. i like it
maybe a thing about taste

@ resistance
thank you for the battle
didnt feel your theme at first but at the end it looks quiet dope =P
good job on that
only thing i dont feel is the blue effect around the ace
doesnt really go with the other colors

congratulations to your victory ;>

[JSFG]

Re: The Resistance Vs. VorthaxX..who will it be?

Lol, I do have a new version but couldn't add it to this. I like yours a lot just think the depth could've been better, lighting it good.

[-Nino-]

Re: The Resistance Vs. VorthaxX..who will it be?

Congratz to OvO on this one.
I like this battle shit, in the future if anyone wants to call someone else out go for it.