[OFFICIAL] Tha Carter V Discussion Thread

[mode]

woah, i respect your opinion but D5 over No Ceilings...

you've went too far

lol run thru it, bar for bar. and when youre done, d5 will be running on for at least another 1200 bars

[cx14xc]

Am I the only one stoked for more wayne x drizzy for c5 but still feelin as if he should leave drake off the album after a song, and juss do a joint tape rather than feat. Drake all over the tracklist.

[Ozzie]

But you called Mac trash, why?

and i know you said compared to Wayne but you must mean currently since Wayne has a 20 year career while Mac has only been here for a few years. And if you're talking currently i have to disagree since WMWTSO >>>>>>> IANAHB2 and Faces >>>>>>> D5 along with the songs he's dropped this year imo

The reason I said he is trash compared to Wayne is cuz that other dude said Mac would rap circles around Wayne. If some1 would rap circles on the other it would be Wayne rapping circles around Mac! Its no way Mac is better then Wayne.

Why even start to compare Mac with Wayne??????? Thats like comparing Mac Miller to Jay Z. Its so stupid.

I think Mac is a great rapper, I like him. But he is no way near to be out rapping Wayne. Just stop. You can start comparing Mac Miller to Wiz Khalifa instead, that makes more sense. Dosent they rap about same things anyways?

- - - Updated - - -

Just because Wayne is spitting better than usual, doesn't mean he's back to form. So yes, there are still a lot of people shitting on Current Wayne even. Quit living under a rock. It's not even to negate Wayne's novelty act progression. It's just not enough to write home about. Not yet at least. Mac, as a rapper, smashes the shit out of Current Wayne. Wayne in the past 4 years even. Sorry.

Fuck off, please

You're worse then cancer, aids and every STD in the world together

[Bp72799]

Man that shit isn't funny

[IAmChristian_]

Nicki on C5 is gonna be dope.

[cy-rus]

lol mac miller doesnt wnt those problems of rapping with wayne on july 8 2014. waynes pretty much on fire..



lol its impressive to me how d5 still gets slept on, even while his current string of work gets praised.. like were you guys on autopilot w the hate.. or just missed the 20 something tracks of foundation he laid for this run...



hmm especially w some of the other performances people champion from as being any good.. D5 is very easily his best project in 5 years, id rate it above no ceilings.. sorry 4 the wait, id rate it above dedication 3.. so thats 6 years or so.. not even sure there was a rap as vicious as what he did on levels on c3..


feels like theres a lot of sentiment and nostalgia goin on.. which really shouldnt be necessary.. if youre interested in wayne the artist express himself, then youve got to know/feel the difference and the departure in this content, than his recent output over the past few years..

and even then, it doesnt mean hes going to bat a thousand, but wayne works best with pace and bulk anyway, nd its almost always more good than bad...

lol you guys forget already how lackadaiscal this dude was rapping, for like 3 years?

Took the words out of my mouth. I love d5 and also think it was the first sign of what's to come. I also think it's better than D3 but still can't say it's better than NC. And levels was honestly Un-fuck-wit-able even for vintage Weezy IMO. I don't think I've heard some shit that hard from him before. Something about it gives me chills

[IAmChristian_]

Took the words out of my mouth. I love d5 and also think it was the first sign of what's to come. I also think it's better than D3 but still can't say it's better than NC. And levels was honestly Un-fuck-wit-able even for vintage Weezy IMO. I don't think I've heard some shit that hard from him before. Something about it gives me chills

Well you can't really compare D3 to any Dedications cause it's pretty much just showcasing him using auto-tune. It's full of dope tracks tho, but it's kinda in it's own league.

[BlackMamba]

getting the feeling that C5 won't be a classic...probably will be a good album tho...

[TheMaker420]

It's still SHOCKING to me how slept on D5 is. And that's not comparing it to his shitty music he's been putting out over the last few years, he's got songs on D5 that people would have rocked with back in 2008-09.

[Bp72799]

For some reason I'm just not excited for C5 anymore I have really no hype right at this moment don't know why it just the way that they been promoting has kinda thrown me off and I'm trying to keep up with the album but i really don't care all that much anymore

[mode]

Took the words out of my mouth. I love d5 and also think it was the first sign of what's to come. I also think it's better than D3 but still can't say it's better than NC. And levels was honestly Un-fuck-wit-able even for vintage Weezy IMO. I don't think I've heard some shit that hard from him before. Something about it gives me chills

levels, to me, was this dedication 2 x drought 3 performance.

you have those few intro bars that remind me of throw some ki's, hes just sort of vibing, and crooning, but then he switches it up, nd blisters the track for two three minutes straight, with some of his tightest writing, weve heard in awhileee, and its non stop too, theres nothing weak, nothing corny or campy. its straight bars, and instead of the juelz feature like it wouldve been on d2, we have vado holding it down.


the reason i have it over no ceilings, is breadth and consistency. the beats were better, and theres nothing as weak as lets say break up, im good, wayne on me, i got no ceilings.

poke her face is cool,but nothing special, sweet little 16, but i might say that literally almost every verse on d5 is better than that one, doa, which he didnt really sink his teeth into, oh lets do it, and im single.

i probably take live life, still got that rock, and you song over no ceilings w birdman, w those being the original songs.. prolly missed some but even there its 3 to 1 ratio...

oh i guess im single, but ill take you song over im single every day of the week.

run this town is hot, but i dont think it outweighs started, uoeno, dontfuckwme, and thats 3 to 1 again..


throw it in the bag is fire, probably the most unique record on no ceilings.


then what you have left is the top 4 records from no ceilings, swag surf, ice cream, watch my shoes, and banned from tv.

all pretty strong, personally not huge on the ice cream beat or watch my shoes, but he killed it.

but dont kill has all the bars of ice cream and watch my shoes, and doesnt have the redundancy of those two records, which.. are essentially the same...

type of way too, its all bars and doesnt fill the same sonic space..


banned from tv is probably better than cream, cos of length and delivery.. but i think the lyricism is sharper, grittier on cream.. and levels picks up.. in its absence neway... or if you want devastation doubles up...

smh, im stil leaving out records on d5 too, itchin is hot, think of you is hot, bugatti is hot, fuckin problems..

its just more sounds, strongver performances, more ambitious..

[dabigone]

DJ Khaled could be on C5.