Tha Carter IV Review

[StevenHTX]

The only mixtapes I really want you to review is Da Drought 3, No Ceilings, and maybe Dedication 2 if you are up to it.

Dedication 4 doesn't deserve a review, becuase I think everybody anticipated D4 with bad expectations, but when it finally dropped, everyone had really mixed feelings.

So just review DD3, NC, and D2 if you want to.

____

You finished the review really great imo.

i agree with the rest of the review.

This album is terrible. I couldn't replay this entire album even if I tried.

President Carter was the only classic on the song because it left a memorable speech at the end.

[IMissTheOldLilWayne]

This was a really good album, im tired of ppl hating on it. The metaphors people hate on c4 are the ones they wud love if he said them in his quote on quote "prime" smh

Never. I'm not a hypocrite. Wayne had shitty ass lines in his prime era, but they were often overlooked because he had a lot of dope ones.



---------- Post added at 12:24 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:21 PM ----------

got money and how to hate is nothing alike.

i wondr how you woul rate c3 and c4 if they came out in 06-07..

I would hate them as much as I hate them now. Nothing different. Who said I love everything before 07? I don't care for the Sqad mixtapes, I hated 500 Degreez, and I didn't care for Tha Block is Hot. I even hate some songs from Lights Out and Suffix.

How To Hate and Got Money are the only songs on C3 to hate T-Pain, that's why I call them alike. I'm not calling them alike because of subject matter or concept, but i'm calling them alike because they're poppy and both of them have T-Pain.

---------- Post added at 12:26 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:24 PM ----------

Oh god... I wanna say something nice, but this shit sound like a Lil Wayne hater wrote it, not a "old Lil Wayne" fan

How exactly? I didn't enjoy this album at all. It was mainstream, too many wack punchlines and it wasn't what I expected after I heard 6'7". I have my opinions and whether you like them or not, that's what I thought when I was listening to this album..

[YM Salute]

Guys, I'm a huge Wayne fan too but we have to sometimes admit when Wayne fell short... I do think How To Love should be higher, but that's not even a rap song, and would've had a whole different approach if used without autotune and possibly gathered a different crowd of people. John could've gotten higher, but those are my opinions.

Also, review Prefix, SQ5 (I think that's the one with Renegade, right?), Dedication 2, Da Drought 3, Dedication 3, No Ceilings, and Dedication 4. When you review these mixtapes I want you to compare them to the original, which you think was better, etc. I'm interested in your reviews on every song Wayne did over a Jay track..

[IMissTheOldLilWayne]

Guys, I'm a huge Wayne fan too but we have to sometimes admit when Wayne fell short... I do think How To Love should be higher, but that's not even a rap song, and would've had a whole different approach if used without autotune and possibly gathered a different crowd of people. John could've gotten higher, but those are my opinions.

Also, review Prefix, SQ5 (I think that's the one with Renegade, right?), Dedication 2, Da Drought 3, Dedication 3, No Ceilings, and Dedication 4. When you review these mixtapes I want you to compare them to the original, which you think was better, etc. I'm interested in your reviews on every song Wayne did over a Jay track..

Thank you for realizing that. And I can agree with you on your decisions, but I had to listen to this album like 3 times non stop, so that's why some tracks are rated low... And I'll review some of the mixtapes, hopefully today.

[ExCluWeeZy]

Disagree with you on John. I like it musically. It's a hard song with lots of swearing as you said, and still a hit. Tough one to argue against IMO...


Other than that I enjoyed the review.

[ThaMothafuckinCarter]

horrible review. way too much hate there were a good 5 tracks on c4 that were 4 or 5 stars and ill let you throwaway the rest to be fair

[IMissTheOldLilWayne]

horrible review. way too much hate there were a good 5 tracks on c4 that were 4 or 5 stars and ill let you throwaway the rest to be fair

Thanks for your insight. And how was there way too much hate? I had to listen to the album 3 times non stop, so that's like 3 hours right there. Then, I had to try to be funny and as un-bias as I could be in the review... But whatever.

[Syko]

Dope review bro.

[RealLife]

Thanks for your insight. And how was there way too much hate? I had to listen to the album 3 times non stop, so that's like 3 hours right there. Then, I had to try to be funny and as un-bias as I could be in the review... But whatever.

Your title should be "Tha C3 vs C4 review".

Without going too much into details, your review is flawed based on the comparison structure you used. Instead of reviewing C4 as an independent body of work, you are benchmarking it against another album, Carter 3... which disqualifies an unbiased review. Carter 3 stands by itself.. so does Carter 4, dont mix the 2... because they mark different times and moments in Lil Wayne's life.

[IMissTheOldLilWayne]

Your title should be "Tha C3 vs C4 review".

Without going too much into details, your review is flawed based on the comparison structure you used. Instead of reviewing C4 as an independent body of work, you are benchmarking it against another album, Carter 3... which disqualifies an unbiased review. Carter 3 stands by itself.. so does Carter 4, dont mix the 2... because they mark different times and moments in Lil Wayne's life.

You're acting like i'm not giving my opinions on this tracks.

[WeezyFan]

Never. I'm not a hypocrite. Wayne had shitty ass lines in his prime era, but they were often overlooked because he had a lot of dope ones.



---------- Post added at 12:24 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:21 PM ----------



I would hate them as much as I hate them now. Nothing different. Who said I love everything before 07? I don't care for the Sqad mixtapes, I hated 500 Degreez, and I didn't care for Tha Block is Hot. I even hate some songs from Lights Out and Suffix.

How To Hate and Got Money are the only songs on C3 to hate T-Pain, that's why I call them alike. I'm not calling them alike because of subject matter or concept, but i'm calling them alike because they're poppy and both of them have T-Pain.

---------- Post added at 12:26 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:24 PM ----------



How exactly? I didn't enjoy this album at all. It was mainstream, too many wack punchlines and it wasn't what I expected after I heard 6'7". I have my opinions and whether you like them or not, that's what I thought when I was listening to this album..

is ''mainstream'' a good reason to hate a album really?

[IMissTheOldLilWayne]

is ''mainstream'' a good reason to hate a album really?

If it's overplayed and all over the place, you eventually get fed up with it.